Error in problem 171 Tree Height Measurement

Back to General discussions forum

Chrisislearning     2025-02-14 17:34:48

For some reason all angles given in the example and input data are obtuse. A right triangle cannot have an obtuse angle. There are also errors in the description:

"So the angle B is 90 degrees when line of sight is horizontal and is 120 degrees when the line of sight is raised 30 degrees above horizont" -No, if the line of sight is raised 30 degrees above the horizon (angle A) then the angle B is 60 degrees (180-90-30=60).

gardengnome     2025-02-14 22:25:21
User avatar
       /
      /
     /B
    /|
   / |
  /  |
 /A  |
-----------
Chrisislearning     2025-02-15 16:23:22

So the B angle is the one outside of the triangle. Weird way to bloat an assignment, but whatever.

zelevin     2025-02-15 22:18:40

This is, however, how things seem to be done in the real world; an example.

Chrisislearning     2025-02-16 19:59:55

I'm curious what would be the reason for it.

zelevin     2025-02-18 14:33:01

The reason is that establishing the downward direction is much easier and more precise (gravity goes there!) than the horizontal direction. A plumb line is a much better tool than, say, a spirit level.

Please login and solve 5 problems to be able to post at forum